NJCAA All-Region 6 (121)
NJCAA All-Region 6 D-I (96)
NJCAA All-Region 6 D-II (25)
| 1999 | Amy Antonich | 1st-Team |
| Traci Kesterson | 1st-Team | |
| Connie Studna | 1st-Team | |
| 2000 | Amy Antonich | 1st-Team |
| Brook Collier | 1st-Team | |
| Traci Kesterson | 1st-Team | |
| Camilla Larson | 1st-Team | |
| Karen Ransom | 1st-Team | |
| Hanna Soderstom | 1st-Team | |
| 2001 | Emily Knop | 1st-Team |
| Rosa Johnston | 1st-Team | |
| Brittany Richman | 2nd-Team | |
| Connie Studna | 1st-Team | |
| Jenny Wallen | 1st-Team | |
| 2002 | Jennifer Johnson | 1st-Team |
| Carlie Kepley | 1st-Team | |
| Paula Rice | 1st-Team | |
| Shannen Taylor | 1st-Team | |
| 2003 | Courtney Ewan | 1st-Team |
| Amy Ganss | 1st-Team | |
| Angie Haworth | 1st-Team | |
| Lisa Sikorski | 1st-Team | |
| Shannon Taylor | Honorable Mention | |
| Casey Kappelman | Honorable Mention | |
| 2004 | Ingrid Bodelson | Honorable Mention |
| Courtney Ewan | Honorable Mention | |
| Amy Ganss | 1st-Team | |
| Brooke Gregory | Honorable Mention | |
| Angie Haworth | Honorable Mention | |
| Fivi Mihai | 1st-Team | |
| 2005 | Elizabeth Casey | 1st-Team |
| Fivi Mihai | 1st-Team | |
| Natahsa Morris | 1st-Team | |
| Chelsea Sheahan | 1st-Team | |
| Brittany Young | 2nd-Team | |
| 2006 | Danielle Blevins | 1st-Team |
| Megan Brown | 1st-Team | |
| Emily Leeper | 1st-Team | |
| Rachelle Luster | 1st-Team | |
| Monique Richardson | 2nd-Team | |
| Chelsea Sheahan | 2nd-Team | |
| 2007 | Megan Brown | 2nd-team |
| Emily Leeper | 1st-Team | |
| Rachelle Luster | 1st-Team | |
| 2008 | Madison Bertrand | 1st-Team |
| Jessica Johnson | 1st-Team | |
| Jessica Smith | 2nd-Team | |
| Chelsea Shepard | Honorable Mention | |
| Kelly Voigts | 2nd-Team | |
| Megan Weston | 1st-Team | |
| 2009 | Alli McMahan | 2nd-Team |
| Whitney Peavler | 1st-Team | |
| Rachel Pride | 1st-Team | |
| Chelsea Shepard | 2nd-Team | |
| Mackenzie Smith | 2nd-Team | |
| Kelly Voigts | 2nd-Team | |
| Megan Weston | 1st-Team | |
| 2010 | Tommi Bouknight | 2nd-Team |
| Jessica Jacob | Honorable Mention | |
| Jenna Neumann | 2nd-Team | |
| Rachel Pride | 2nd-Team | |
| Kaylee Sextro | Honorable Mention | |
| Mackenzie Smith | 2nd-Team | |
| Whitney Peavler | 1st-Team | |
| 2011 | Tommi Bouknight | 1st-Team |
| Emma Crenshaw | 1st-Team | |
| Phoenix Keane | 2nd-Team | |
| Haley Wagner | 1st-Team | |
| 2012 | Christy Tran | 2nd-Team |
| Kelsey Wakefield | 2nd-Team | |
| 2013 | Carsyn Beard | 1st-Team |
| Courtney Hughes | 1st-Team | |
| Christy Tran | 1st-Team | |
| Janay Stone | 2nd-Team | |
| Kelsey Wakefield | 2nd-Team | |
| 2014 | Jenn Howell | 2nd-Team |
| Courtney Hughes | 2nd-Team | |
| Brooklynn Meinke | 1st-Team | |
| Ashlynn Summar | 1st-Team | |
| 2015 | Sydney Alexander | 1st-Team |
| Tori Devenshire | 1st-Team | |
| Taryn Kruse | 2nd-Team | |
| Ashlynn Summar | 1st-Team | |
| 2016 | Joanna Taylor | 2nd-Team |
| Sarah Taylor | 1st-Team | |
| 2017 | Jesse Cummings | 2nd-Team |
| Manuela Gonzalez | 1st-Team | |
| Vanessa Silva | 2nd-Team | |
| Georgia Vernardakis | 1st-Team | |
| 2018 | Georgia Vernardakis | 1st-Team |
| 2019 | Kayla Brashear | 2nd-Team |
| 2020 | Darrian Gordon | Honorable Mention |
| Tio Krizogono | 2nd-Team | |
| Abigail Logan | 1st-Team | |
| Alexa Pittman | 2nd-Team | |
| 2022 | Monique Fair | 2nd-Team |
| 2023• | Alandra Bailey | 1st-Team |
| Monana-Rose Currey | 1st-Team | |
| Megan Everhart | 1st-Team | |
| Maddox Fergus | 2nd-Team | |
| Sydney Hammett | 1st-Team | |
| Jenna Kinght | 1st-Team | |
| Willoughby Lam | 1st-Team | |
| Sydney Puetz | 1st-Team | |
| Maya Wallace | 1st-Team | |
| 2024• | Emily Crosby | 1st-Team |
| Montana-Rose Currey | 1st-Team | |
| Maddox Fergus | 1st-Team | |
| Brecken Hoy | 1st-Team | |
| Karsen Koehler | 1st-Team | |
| Lily Marshall | 1st-Team | |
| Sydney Puetz | 1st-Team | |
| Maya Wallace | 1st-Team | |
| 2025• | Tatum Bresette | 1st-Team |
| Ashley Chaput | 1st-Team | |
| Carmen Duarte | 1st-Team | |
| Brecken Hoy | 1st-Team | |
| Eleanor Marshall | 2nd-Team | |
| Lily Marshall | 1st-Team | |
| Carson Sloan | 1st-Team | |
| Avery Young | 1st-Team | |
| • D-II |
NJCAA Region VI Player of the Year (4)
| 1999 | Amy Antonich |
| 2001 | Jenny Wallen |
| 2002 | Shannen Taylor |
| 2006 | Rachelle Luster |